
Andrew Scott is trending in America right now — and this time it's not for playing a supervillain or a hot priest. The Irish actor's new film Elsinore opens in US theaters this Friday, November 20, and critics have already used the word "devastating" so many times it should probably be in the credits. Scott plays Ian Charleson, the Chariots of Fire star who kept performing Hamlet on the National Theatre stage while secretly dying of AIDS — and awards watchers are calling Scott the frontrunner for Best Actor at the Oscars, where he could make history as the first openly gay winner of an acting Oscar. Here's everything behind the trend: the film, the true story that's wrecking audiences, and the career that led here.
Why is Andrew Scott trending in America right now?
The timing is a perfect storm. Elsinore premieres in limited US release this Friday, November 20, via Focus Features — the studio that knows exactly how to run an awards campaign. The film premiered at the Telluride Film Festival in September, then won the International People's Choice Award at the Toronto International Film Festival on September 20 — a prize with a long track record of foreshadowing Oscar contenders. Since then: an Acting Award at Mill Valley, an Audience Award in San Diego, a Marquee Award at the SCAD Savannah Film Festival, and a Gotham Award nomination for Outstanding Lead Performance (the ceremony lands November 30). Last week it was announced Scott will receive the Desert Palm Achievement Award at the Palm Springs Film Festival. Awards season just opened, and one name is already everywhere.
What is Elsinore about? The true story of Ian Charleson
Elsinore — the title nods to Hamlet's castle in Denmark — is a biographical drama directed by Simon Stone and written by Stephen Beresford, running 111 minutes. Andrew Scott plays Ian Charleson, the Scottish actor immortalized as Eric Liddell in Chariots of Fire, the 1981 film that won the Best Picture Oscar. The story covers Charleson's final chapter: privately diagnosed with AIDS, refusing to give up the role of a lifetime, he performed Hamlet at the National Theatre night after night while hiding an illness the public wouldn't learn about until after his death in January 1990, at just 40.
The cast around him is ridiculous in the best way: Olivia Colman as Margaret Johnson, Charleson's doctor, and Johnny Flynn as Richard Eyre, the director staging his Hamlet — with Billie Piper, Luke Thompson, David Dawson, Joe Locke, Monica Dolan, Adeel Akhtar, Juliet Stevenson and Peter Mullan filling out the ensemble. And today, the Ian Charleson Awards, which honor the best young classical stage actors, still carry his name.
The reviews are in — and critics are wrecked
On Rotten Tomatoes the film sits at 89% from 66 critics (averaging 7.8/10), with a Metacritic score of 75. The praise isn't for the film so much as for its lead. The Irish Times wrote that Scott shows "why he's one of the great actors of our age" amid "the deafening Oscar buzz." Variety's Owen Gleiberman called it "an art-house crowd-pleaser," while Britain's Independent collected reviews under the word "devastating." One five-star review, per HuffPost, claimed Scott has "all but secured the Best Actor trophy." When festival juries and critics say the same thing at the same time, that's usually how frontrunners are born.
The Oscar history Andrew Scott could make
Here's why this trend has real weight: The Hollywood Reporter reported that the response to Scott's performance has been so tremendous there's already significant chatter he could become the first out gay person to ever win an acting Oscar. Scott himself addressed the weight of that possibility beautifully: "Nobody wants to be rewarded or awarded for anything other than their work — you don't want to be a token — but Ian and his predecessors weren't invited to do the work... they could have had the facility to do [it], and that must have been so painful and difficult to have to choose between one thing or the other."
And then the line that defines his journey: "I thought when I was starting out that that was my fate too, but bit by bit... that's turned out not to be the case. That's why it's so important for me to say not just that I managed to scrape by, but actually that I've been able to thrive in this situation, and that feels genuinely extraordinary."
One delicious detail for theater fans: Scott has played Hamlet himself, in the Almeida Theatre's acclaimed 2017 production. He's not acting the role of a stage legend from the outside — he knows exactly what that burden feels like.
From Moriarty to the Hot Priest: the career behind the frontrunner
If you only know Andrew Scott from memes, here's the resume. Born in Dublin on October 21, 1976 — he turned 50 last month — he became a phenomenon as Jim Moriarty in BBC's Sherlock, winning a BAFTA for making "Hi" the most chilling greeting on television. Then came Fleabag's Hot Priest, a role so beloved it earned him an Emmy nomination and permanently attached the phrase "hot priest" to his name. Between those: the indie gem Pride (2014), a villain in Spectre (2015), the Emmy-nominated Netflix limited series Ripley (2024), and a celebrated one-man staging of Vanya. The pattern of his career: he steals every film he's in. Elsinore is the first time he's the engine — and the industry is watching what happens.
Where and when to watch Elsinore
Focus Features opens the film in limited US release this Friday, November 20, with the platform rollout expanding through awards season. International audiences follow: Italy gets it January 28, 2027 (Lucky Red), and the UK on January 29, 2027 (StudioCanal). If the pattern of Telluride-to-Oscar films holds, the wide release will land at peak nomination momentum.
Quick answers for fans
- Why is Andrew Scott trending? His new film Elsinore opens in US theaters November 20 — and he's the critics' frontrunner for Best Actor, with a Gotham Award nomination already in hand.
- What is Elsinore about? The true story of Chariots of Fire star Ian Charleson, who performed Hamlet at the National Theatre while secretly dying of AIDS.
- Who was Ian Charleson? The Scottish actor who played Eric Liddell in Chariots of Fire (1981's Best Picture winner); he died in 1990 at 40.
- Could Andrew Scott really win an Oscar? Critics and awards watchers call him the Best Actor frontrunner — and The Hollywood Reporter notes he could become the first out gay person to win an acting Oscar.
- How old is Andrew Scott? He is 50 — born October 21, 1976, in Dublin.
You can read the full film details at Wikipedia, Scott's career-defining interview at The Hollywood Reporter, the critics' reactions at The Independent, the trailer news at IMDb, and his Palm Springs honor at MyNewsLA. Now the question: is this Andrew Scott's Oscar year — or will the season surprise us? Watch the trailer, see the film this weekend, and come back to the comments to tell us if it wrecked you too.
Comments
Post a Comment