
The results are in, and one kitchen legend just beat them all. A fresh taste test cooked through four famous celebrity mashed potato recipes — from Martha Stewart, Ina Garten, Snoop Dogg, and Julia Child — and the winner was not the star most people expected. With Thanksgiving 2026 less than two weeks away, here is exactly which recipe belongs on your holiday table, and the surprising secret ingredient that almost stole the crown.
Which celebrity mashed potato recipe is the best for Thanksgiving?
Four iconic recipes went head to head this holiday season: Martha Stewart's "perfect" mashed potatoes, Ina Garten's garlic mash, Snoop Dogg's creamy mayonnaise mash, and Julia Child's rich béchamel potatoes. Every dish was judged on taste, texture, richness, and how easy it was to prepare in a real home kitchen.
The final ranking turned out very different from what most fans predict. The most classic recipe landed in last place, a rapper's unusual trick nearly won everything, and a cooking legend from decades ago proved she still cannot be beaten. If you follow a popular celebrity for kitchen inspiration, these results will make you see your favorite stars in a whole new way.
- 1. Julia Child — the winner (4.5 out of 5). The beloved French cooking icon took the top spot with the most ambitious recipe of the group. Her potatoes get folded into a garlic-butter béchamel sauce thickened with flour, then finished with plenty of fresh parsley. The result is super fluffy with a deep garlic flavor, and the thick, velvety texture holds up beautifully under hot gravy. Judges gave it a perfect score for taste.
- 2. Snoop Dogg — the wild card (4 out of 5). The rap superstar hides a surprising secret in his mash: mayonnaise. Combined with cream and butter, it creates the richest, most decadent potatoes of the whole test, with a slight tang that testers loved. It is definitely not an everyday side dish, but for a special holiday feast it is almost impossible to beat.
- 3. Ina Garten — the light and elegant choice (3.5 out of 5). The Barefoot Contessa skips butter entirely and uses olive oil with mellow confit garlic and cream. Her mash tastes lighter than the others, has a gorgeous rich yellow color, and delivers a gentle garlic flavor that never overpowers the meal.
- 4. Martha Stewart — the classic that fell short (3 out of 5). The queen of entertaining keeps it simple with milk, butter, and a pinch of nutmeg, mashed with a food mill, ricer, or stand mixer. Testers found the flavor classically creamy, but the texture came out chunky and loose, and the nutmeg divided the room.
Why do famous holiday side dishes matter to everyday home cooks?
Cooking for the holidays can cause a lot of stress for people hosting big family dinners. Trying a tested recipe from a famous star removes the scary guesswork from holiday planning. You can feel confident that your side dish will taste great, because someone already cooked and compared all four options for you.
Using top celebrity mashed potato recipes also brings fun conversation to the dinner table. Your guests will love guessing whether their potatoes came from Snoop Dogg or Martha Stewart. It turns a basic side dish into a talking point that keeps everyone smiling while they share their meal.
How can you make the winning Julia Child potatoes for your family?
The winning recipe takes a little extra work, but the steps are simple when you break them down. Here is how to bring Julia Child's Thanksgiving champion to your own table:
- Peel russet potatoes, cut them into even chunks, and boil them in salted water until completely fork-tender.
- Mash the potatoes until smooth and lump free.
- In a saucepan, melt a generous amount of butter with minced garlic, then whisk in flour to create the base of the sauce.
- Slowly pour in warm milk while whisking until the béchamel turns thick and silky.
- Fold the garlic béchamel into the mashed potatoes instead of plain butter and milk.
- Finish with a good amount of chopped fresh parsley, season with salt, and serve hot.
One smart tip from the test: the béchamel sauce can be made in advance. Prepare it the night before, then fold everything together right before dinner. That little shortcut makes the most labor-intensive recipe of the test much easier on the big day.
What should you plan next for your holiday meal menu?
After you pick the absolute best potato recipe, you can start choosing your other side dishes. You might want to compare famous recipes for stuffing, gravy, and sweet pies next, or even test Snoop Dogg's mayonnaise mash as a fun surprise plate. Building a full table of tried and true food makes your host job much easier this year.
You can read the full ranking and every score in the original taste test at BuzzFeed, or learn more about the winner's incredible life story at Julia Child. Keep watching popular food blogs and news pages for more fun recipe tests before the big day arrives. With Julia's winning potatoes ready to go, your holiday feast is already halfway to a massive success.
Which of these four recipes would you try first? Tell us in the comments, and share this taste test with the person who always cooks Thanksgiving dinner at your house.
Comments
Post a Comment